Effective College Football Play-by-Play Ratings for Week 12:

We lost our five-week winning streak on my Effective Play-by-Play projections in Week 11 of college football, but by only the slightest of margins, a 33-34 ATS record. It would have been a few games worse had the final lines in the Michigan-Oregon, LSU-Texas and UNLV-New Mexico games not flipped the edge to the other team. I explained this last week that line moves throughout the week can flip the edges. Be sure to note how lines are moving before investing, especially on the smaller-differential games. That said, for the last six weeks, our full-season model is at 190-164-1 ATS (53.7%). This has produced nearly 10 units of profit in that stretch. 

As a quick reminder, Effective Play-by-Play Ratings differ from my Effective Strength Ratings. Rather than simply gauging the end result, they evaluate a team’s performance across all scrimmage plays. Both models account for each team’s schedule to date. 

Some prefer this approach to traditional power ratings based on scoring because the latter can be skewed by fluky plays, turnovers, fourth-down conversions, and other factors. Both methods have value, and combining different measures of team strength may be the best approach. Personally, I believe Effective Play-by-Play Ratings may offer a more accurate picture of team strength because they draw on a much larger data sample. That’s particularly useful in college football, where talent disparities between teams can be enormous. 

All the strength ratings discussed here are adjusted for schedule strength, account for games that became noncompetitive late and include relevant injury adjustments. 

For this week’s update, I wanted to share some top 25 CFB and NFL data since a reader asked which teams were the best right now, as the CFP and NFL playoffs are coming before you know it. Here are the most recent numbers:

College Football Top 25 in Effective Play-by-Play Strength:

Rank. Team: Equivalent Eff PxP PR

1. GEORGIA: 80.2

2. WAKE FOREST: 70

3. OHIO STATE: 69.1

4. ALABAMA: 68.6

5. MIAMI FL: 68.5

6. LOUISVILLE: 68.3

7. INDIANA: 67.3

8. LSU: 67.2

9. UCLA: 67.1

10. NOTRE DAME: 66.8

11. TEXAS: 63

12. OKLAHOMA STATE: 60.9

13. UTAH: 60.9

14. SOUTH CAROLINA: 60.6

15. OREGON: 60.5

16. BYU: 59.9

17. KENTUCKY: 59.2

18. IOWA: 58.8

19. FLORIDA: 58.7

20. NORTHWESTERN: 58.1

21. MISSOURI: 57.7

22. ARIZONA: 57.6

23. MISSISSIPPI STATE: 57.5

24. OLE MISS: 56.5

25. NEBRASKA: 56.4

You might recognize that all of the top 25 teams right now are Power 4 conference schools (or Notre Dame). The highest-rated Group of 6 program is Texas State in 28th. Take the top 11 plus TSU and you could get a good feel for what this metric thinks the 2026 CFP bracket might look like. You could substitute Utah for LSU at 13 and 8, respectively, and get a realistic field. Interesting, at this point, Georgia is 10.2 points better than any other team as we head down the stretch.

Pro Football Ranking in Effective Play-by-Play Strength:

Rank. Team: Equivalent Eff PxP PR

1. SAN FRANCISCO: 37.4

2. SEATTLE: 34.5

3. KANSAS CITY: 33.2

4. BUFFALO: 30.8

5. LA RAMS: 29.1

6. CINCINNATI: 28.1

7. DETROIT: 28

8. GREEN BAY: 28

9. CAROLINA: 27.3

10. BALTIMORE: 26.6

11. JACKSONVILLE: 26.2

12. NY JETS: 25.4

13. TAMPA BAY: 25.4

14. ATLANTA: 25.3

15. NEW ENGLAND: 25.3

16. MINNESOTA: 24.6

17. HOUSTON: 24.5

18. CLEVELAND: 24.2

19. NY GIANTS: 23.8

20. WASHINGTON: 23.8

21. MIAMI: 22.5

22. DENVER: 21.9

23. PITTSBURGH: 20

24. CHICAGO: 19.7

25. LA CHARGERS: 19.6

26. ARIZONA: 18.2

27. PHILADELPHIA: 17.4

28. DALLAS: 16.3

29. NEW ORLEANS: 16.3

30. TENNESSEE: 15.7

31. LAS VEGAS: 15.2

32. INDIANAPOLIS: 11.4

As you can see, the top two teams in the NFL on an effective play-by-play basis, according to my numbers, are NFC powers San Francisco and Seattle. Their division mate, the Rams, check in at No. 5. This list can highlight teams that are perhaps over- or underrated. On that note, you are probably wondering why Chicago is ranked so far down the list at 24th. Their effective defensive yards per play shows the Bears allow opponents to gain 0.72 yards per play more than their average. That ranks ahead of only the Raiders. Obviously, Chicago has overcome that and has improved in recent weeks, but it is still a legitimate concern. Jacksonville is in a similar, perhaps overrated, situation in that the Jaguars’ numbers are respectable overall, but they’ve come against one of the league’s easiest schedules. 

As I wrap up, here are the Week 12 college football games in their usual fashion, ordered by the discrepancy between the Effective Play-by-Play line and the actual line. You may notice that the margins of the edges seem to be shrinking more and more each week into more normalized territory as the data sample grows.

(423) WASHINGTON STATE at (424) TEXAS STATE
Actual Line: TEXAS STATE -10.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TEXAS STATE -25.2
Difference: 14.7, Favors – TEXAS STATE 

(373) NORTHWESTERN at (374) MINNESOTA
Actual Line: MINNESOTA +3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MINNESOTA +17.7
Difference: 14.7, Favors – NORTHWESTERN

(323) UTEP at (324) AIR FORCE
Actual Line: AIR FORCE -22.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: AIR FORCE -8.5
Difference: 14, Favors – UTEP

(401) UCLA at (402) MICHIGAN
Actual Line: MICHIGAN +3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MICHIGAN +16.1
Difference: 12.6, Favors – UCLA

(355) NORTH CAROLINA at (356) VIRGINIA
Actual Line: VIRGINIA -1.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: VIRGINIA +10.9
Difference: 12.4, Favors – NORTH CAROLINA

(319) BOWLING GREEN at (320) TOLEDO
Actual Line: TOLEDO -15.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TOLEDO -26.7
Difference: 11.2, Favors – TOLEDO

(417) NORTHERN ILLINOIS at (418) NORTH DAKOTA STATE
Actual Line: NORTH DAKOTA STATE -25.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NORTH DAKOTA STATE -14.9
Difference: 10.6, Favors – NORTHERN ILLINOIS

(363) VIRGINIA TECH at (364) MIAMI FL
Actual Line: MIAMI FL -20.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MIAMI FL -31.1
Difference: 10.6, Favors – MIAMI FL

(387) MIDDLE TENNESSEE STATE at (388) SAM HOUSTON STATE
Actual Line: SAM HOUSTON STATE +5.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: SAM HOUSTON STATE -4.6
Difference: 10.1, Favors – SAM HOUSTON STATE

(415) OLD DOMINION at (416) CONNECTICUT
Actual Line: CONNECTICUT -13.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: CONNECTICUT -23.3
Difference: 9.8, Favors – CONNECTICUT

(377) SOUTH ALABAMA at (378) SOUTHERN MISS
Actual Line: SOUTHERN MISS +3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: SOUTHERN MISS -5.7
Difference: 9.2, Favors – SOUTHERN MISS

(389) HAWAII at (390) NEVADA
Actual Line: NEVADA -4
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NEVADA -12.8
Difference: 8.8, Favors – NEVADA

(413) INDIANA at (414) WASHINGTON
Actual Line: WASHINGTON +7.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: WASHINGTON +16.1
Difference: 8.6, Favors – INDIANA

(333) PITTSBURGH at (334) LOUISVILLE
Actual Line: LOUISVILLE -14
Effective Play-by-Play Line: LOUISVILLE -22.5
Difference: 8.5, Favors – LOUISVILLE

(309) AKRON at (310) MASSACHUSETTS
Actual Line: MASSACHUSETTS -3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MASSACHUSETTS -11.4
Difference: 8.4, Favors – MASSACHUSETTS

(433) UTAH STATE at (434) OREGON STATE
Actual Line: OREGON STATE -9.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: OREGON STATE -17.6
Difference: 8.1, Favors – OREGON STATE

(407) LSU at (408) TENNESSEE
Actual Line: TENNESSEE +1.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TENNESSEE +9.4
Difference: 7.9, Favors – LSU

(367) OHIO STATE at (368) NEBRASKA
Actual Line: NEBRASKA +3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NEBRASKA +10.6
Difference: 7.6, Favors – OHIO STATE

(429) COLORADO STATE at (430) FRESNO STATE
Actual Line: FRESNO STATE -20.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: FRESNO STATE -13
Difference: 7.5, Favors – COLORADO STATE

(385) OKLAHOMA STATE at (386) ARIZONA STATE
Actual Line: ARIZONA STATE +3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: ARIZONA STATE +10.3
Difference: 7.3, Favors – OKLAHOMA STATE

(425) UNLV at (426) SAN JOSE STATE
Actual Line: SAN JOSE STATE +7
Effective Play-by-Play Line: SAN JOSE STATE +0.2
Difference: 6.8, Favors – SAN JOSE STATE

(345) SOUTH FLORIDA at (346) FLORIDA ATLANTIC
Actual Line: FLORIDA ATLANTIC +1.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: FLORIDA ATLANTIC +8.1
Difference: 6.6, Favors – SOUTH FLORIDA

(395) DELAWARE at (396) NEW MEXICO STATE
Actual Line: NEW MEXICO STATE +3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NEW MEXICO STATE -3.1
Difference: 6.6, Favors – NEW MEXICO STATE

(409) ARIZONA at (410) KANSAS STATE
Actual Line: KANSAS STATE +7
Effective Play-by-Play Line: KANSAS STATE +13.4
Difference: 6.4, Favors – ARIZONA

(427) SMU at (428) NOTRE DAME
Actual Line: NOTRE DAME -20.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NOTRE DAME -14.4
Difference: 6.1, Favors – SMU

(305) EASTERN MICHIGAN at (306) WESTERN MICHIGAN
Actual Line: WESTERN MICHIGAN -15.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: WESTERN MICHIGAN -21.4
Difference: 5.9, Favors – WESTERN MICHIGAN

(337) RUTGERS at (338) PENN STATE
Actual Line: PENN STATE -24.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: PENN STATE -18.6
Difference: 5.9, Favors – RUTGERS

(341) GEORGIA STATE at (342) MARSHALL
Actual Line: MARSHALL -1.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MARSHALL +4.4
Difference: 5.9, Favors – GEORGIA STATE

(327) TEXAS-SAN ANTONIO at (328) UAB
Actual Line: UAB +6.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: UAB +0.8
Difference: 5.7, Favors – UAB

(365) TEXAS TECH at (366) BAYLOR
Actual Line: BAYLOR +3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: BAYLOR -2.1
Difference: 5.6, Favors – BAYLOR

(317) CLEMSON at (318) DUKE
Actual Line: DUKE -12.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: DUKE -18
Difference: 5.5, Favors – DUKE

(379) CHARLOTTE at (380) TULSA
Actual Line: TULSA -22.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TULSA -17.2
Difference: 5.3, Favors – CHARLOTTE

(383) MISSOURI STATE at (384) JACKSONVILLE STATE
Actual Line: JACKSONVILLE STATE -10.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: JACKSONVILLE STATE -15.7
Difference: 5.2, Favors – JACKSONVILLE STATE

(329) SYRACUSE at (330) BOSTON COLLEGE
Actual Line: BOSTON COLLEGE +2.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: BOSTON COLLEGE -2.6
Difference: 5.1, Favors – BOSTON COLLEGE

(349) LOUISIANA-MONROE at (350) APPALACHIAN STATE
Actual Line: APPALACHIAN STATE -14
Effective Play-by-Play Line: APPALACHIAN STATE -19
Difference: 5, Favors – APPALACHIAN STATE

(347) WISCONSIN at (348) PURDUE
Actual Line: PURDUE +6
Effective Play-by-Play Line: PURDUE +10.5
Difference: 4.5, Favors – WISCONSIN

(339) EAST CAROLINA at (340) ARMY
Actual Line: ARMY -5.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: ARMY -1
Difference: 4.5, Favors – EAST CAROLINA

(393) MARYLAND at (394) USC
Actual Line: USC -17.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: USC -13.1
Difference: 4.4, Favors – MARYLAND

(307) CENTRAL MICHIGAN at (308) BUFFALO
Actual Line: BUFFALO -1.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: BUFFALO +2.8
Difference: 4.3, Favors – CENTRAL MICHIGAN

(421) KENTUCKY at (422) MISSOURI
Actual Line: MISSOURI -5.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MISSOURI -1.3
Difference: 4.2, Favors – KENTUCKY

(303) BALL STATE at (304) OHIO U
Actual Line: OHIO U -10
Effective Play-by-Play Line: OHIO U -14
Difference: 4, Favors – OHIO U

(371) TEXAS A&M at (372) OKLAHOMA
Actual Line: OKLAHOMA -7.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: OKLAHOMA -11.4
Difference: 3.9, Favors – OKLAHOMA

(419) GEORGIA SOUTHERN at (420) TROY
Actual Line: TROY +8.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TROY +12
Difference: 3.5, Favors – GEORGIA SOUTHERN

(405) NORTH TEXAS at (406) TULANE
Actual Line: TULANE +6
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TULANE +9.3
Difference: 3.3, Favors – NORTH TEXAS

(357) HOUSTON at (358) WEST VIRGINIA
Actual Line: WEST VIRGINIA +8.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: WEST VIRGINIA +11.8
Difference: 3.3, Favors – HOUSTON

(325) NEW MEXICO at (326) WYOMING
Actual Line: WYOMING +7.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: WYOMING +4.5
Difference: 3, Favors – WYOMING

(361) WAKE FOREST at (362) GEORGIA TECH
Actual Line: GEORGIA TECH +21
Effective Play-by-Play Line: GEORGIA TECH +23.9
Difference: 2.9, Favors – WAKE FOREST

(397) FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL at (398) KENNESAW STATE
Actual Line: KENNESAW STATE -3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: KENNESAW STATE -0.6
Difference: 2.9, Favors – FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL

(369) ARKANSAS STATE at (370) LOUISIANA TECH
Actual Line: LOUISIANA TECH -13.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: LOUISIANA TECH -16.2
Difference: 2.7, Favors – LOUISIANA TECH

(391) STANFORD at (392) CALIFORNIA
Actual Line: CALIFORNIA +2.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: CALIFORNIA +5.1
Difference: 2.6, Favors – STANFORD

(335) NC STATE at (336) FLORIDA STATE
Actual Line: FLORIDA STATE -9.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: FLORIDA STATE -12.1
Difference: 2.6, Favors – FLORIDA STATE

(359) IOWA at (360) ILLINOIS
Actual Line: ILLINOIS +8.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: ILLINOIS +6.1
Difference: 2.4, Favors – ILLINOIS

(331) VANDERBILT at (332) FLORIDA
Actual Line: FLORIDA -13.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: FLORIDA -15.9
Difference: 2.4, Favors – FLORIDA

(399) UTAH at (400) TCU
Actual Line: TCU +7
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TCU +9.1
Difference: 2.1, Favors – UTAH

(351) COLORADO at (352) CINCINNATI
Actual Line: CINCINNATI -3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: CINCINNATI -1.1
Difference: 1.9, Favors – COLORADO

(381) WESTERN KENTUCKY at (382) LIBERTY
Actual Line: LIBERTY -17.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: LIBERTY -19.3
Difference: 1.8, Favors – LIBERTY

(313) RICE at (314) TEMPLE
Actual Line: TEMPLE -3
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TEMPLE -1.3
Difference: 1.7, Favors – RICE

(321) OREGON at (322) MICHIGAN STATE
Actual Line: MICHIGAN STATE +16.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: MICHIGAN STATE +18.1
Difference: 1.6, Favors – OREGON

(375) COASTAL CAROLINA at (376) LOUISIANA
Actual Line: LOUISIANA -10.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: LOUISIANA -12
Difference: 1.5, Favors – LOUISIANA

(411) ARKANSAS at (412) TEXAS
Actual Line: TEXAS -20.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: TEXAS -21.8
Difference: 1.3, Favors – TEXAS

(315) IOWA STATE at (316) UCF
Actual Line: UCF -2.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: UCF -1.6
Difference: 0.9, Favors – IOWA STATE

(431) SAN DIEGO STATE at (432) BOISE STATE
Actual Line: BOISE STATE -16.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: BOISE STATE -17.3
Difference: 0.8, Favors – BOISE STATE

(301) MIAMI OHIO at (302) KENT STATE
Actual Line: KENT STATE +9.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: KENT STATE +10
Difference: 0.5, Favors – MIAMI OHIO

(353) MEMPHIS at (354) NAVY
Actual Line: NAVY +3.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: NAVY +3.3
Difference: 0.2, Favors – NAVY

(403) GEORGIA at (404) SOUTH CAROLINA
Actual Line: SOUTH CAROLINA +16.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: SOUTH CAROLINA +16.6
Difference: 0.1, Favors – GEORGIA

(343) BYU at (344) KANSAS
Actual Line: KANSAS +5.5
Effective Play-by-Play Line: KANSAS +5.5
Difference: 0, Favors – NONE

SPONSORED

RECORD BREAKER!  ROBERT FERRINGO just had one of the biggest football weeks in Doc’s Sports’ 56-year history! Robert banked +3,720 with his football picks (documented HERE) and added another +2,350 with his football props (documented HERE). That is an electrifying +6,070 in winnings and he’s looking to add to it this weekend!

Access his premium picks at Doc’s Sports with a free $60 new member account. Get your free trial here!

Previous articleNHL Predictions: Expert Picks on Tuesday, November 17
Steve Makinen
As one of the original founders of StatFox, Steve Makinen has been in the business of sports betting and data analysis for almost 25 years now. In his time in the industry, Steve has worked in a variety of capacities on both sides of the betting counter, from his early days of developing the StatFox business, to almost a decade of oddsmaking consulting for one of the world's leading sportsbooks, to his last seven years as Point Spread Weekly and Analytics Director with VSiN. Steve has always believed that number crunching and handicapping through foundational trends and systems is the secret to success and he shares this data with VSiN readers on a daily basis for all of the major sports.