Week 12 College Football Best Bets, Predictions and Picks from Matt Youmans

Arguing about where teams are ranked by the clueless College Football Playoff committee gets tiresome. It is sometimes entertaining because of all the stupidity involved, but it’s more often a lame weekly routine. Another topic to argue — and one I would rather entertain — is which program is the bigger mess this season: LSU or Michigan?

The Wolverines are coached by an old-timer who was fading fast and chased out of Utah. The Kyle Whittingham reclamation project is a bust, and the buyout is around $25 million if he’s fired after the season. He should be done. Michigan (5-5) has wasted millions on a quarterback who was benched and an offensive coordinator who was fired.

The Tigers courted soap opera diva/coach Lane Kiffin with a $90 million contract and signed quarterback Sam Leavitt for around $5 million. Leavitt threw three interceptions in a 22-21 loss to Texas last week. While most of the SEC appears in the CFP rankings, LSU (6-4) does not, and Kiffin gets my vote for the biggest loser. But it’s a close call.

After debating the UCLA-Michigan and LSU-Tennessee games all week, I have decided to pass for now. My leans are to the Bruins and Volunteers, but both games smell fishy. The excruciating loss I just took with LSU was the lowlight of my second straight losing week. When you hit a skid, it’s always a combination of bad handicapping and bad luck, so I’ll look to turn things around with five best bets for Week 12.

Ohio State (-3) at Nebraska

Matt Rhule and the Cornhuskers will have to prove it because it’s difficult to bet on something that never happens. Rhule has lost 21 consecutive games against ranked opponents as a coach, and Nebraska has dropped 31 straight versus ranked opponents. The Cornhuskers played well in one-score losses to Indiana and Oregon, but failing to close the deal in big games is a troubling trend and their six wins have come at the expense of weak teams — Ohio, Bowling Green, North Dakota, Michigan State, Maryland and Rutgers.

The Buckeyes have dropped three games and coach Ryan Day is getting exposed again, but they are hanging around the CFP hunt. Freshman quarterback Luke Fahey appears to be getting more comfortable after three starts. Fahey passed for three touchdowns and Bo Jackson ran for 114 of the team’s 168 yards in a victory over Northwestern. I don’t believe wide receiver Jeremiah Smith deserves to be the Heisman Trophy favorite, but he will be the best player on the field in this game. While the betting market is moving to 3.5, Circa Sports still offers -3.

Best Bet: Ohio State -3 (-120)

Wisconsin (-6) at Purdue

The Badgers would be better off losing this game and firing coach Luke Fickell, who just lost to a miserable Maryland team with an interim coach. Wisconsin has not had a 100-yard passer in four of its past five games — freshman Ryan Hopkins passed for 241 yards against Rutgers — yet should top that low bar against a bad Purdue defense. This is a huge game for the home underdog because coach Barry Odom’s rebuilding project is losing steam and he’s losing support. The Boilermakers are stuck with an 18-game losing streak in this series, dating to the Joe Tiller era. Odom needs a win like this before it gets too ugly. Purdue has the superior quarterback in Ryan Browne, a tough running back in Fame Ijeboi and a shot to pull the minor upset against what could be a lame-duck coach in Fickell.

Best Bet: Purdue +6

UNLV (-7) at San Jose State

This is a classic letdown spot for the Rebels, who became bowl-eligible and picked up their first win over a ranked opponent in 18 years by stunning New Mexico 21-17. Jackson Arnold resembled Patrick Mahomes by passing for 201 yards and two touchdowns and running for 98 yards, including a 44-yard touchdown to win it in the fourth quarter. UNLV coach Dan Mullen was running around the field in Albuquerque looking for anyone to hug and a Lombardi Trophy to hoist. Now the Rebels go to a sleepy atmosphere in San Jose. The Spartans (5-6), getting decent play from quarterbacks Luke Weaver and Daniel Rolovich, hung tough in a 21-16 loss to the Lobos on Halloween.

Best Bet: San Jose State +7

Utah (-7.5) at Texas Christian

How much do the Utes have left in the emotional gas tank after dramatic victories over BYU and Arizona? Senior quarterback Devon Dampier was dynamic in the 40-39 win in Tucson by passing for 204 yards, running for 100 and accounting for four touchdowns as Utah rolled up 500 total yards. Back-to-back road games are never easy situations and this one should be particularly tough. TCU (5-5) has suffered five one-score losses. The Horned Frogs rank 12th in the nation in scoring defense (15.2 ppg), and senior quarterback Jaden Craig has been showing improvement. As Fox Sports analyst Chris Fallica pointed out, there were 13 AP top 15 teams on the road against unranked opponents in the past four weeks and the ranked teams went 7-6. The nation’s No. 2 team should be on upset alert in Fort Worth.

Best Bet: TCU +7.5

Hawaii at Nevada (-5.5)

On a cold night in Reno, the conditions favor the Wolf Pack, who are sitting at 4-6 and still have a goal to reach a bowl. Nevada has two good running backs, Herschel Turner and Dominic Kelley, and a pass defense that ranks sixth in the nation (161 yards per game). A strong pass defense is important in this matchup because Hawaii’s offense is ineffective on the ground and relies almost completely on error-prone quarterback Micah Alejado, who threw two costly interceptions in a loss to North Dakota State last week. The Warriors (3-7) see no bowl hopes at the end of the rainbow, so their motivation will be lacking. Hawaii’s defense has been sturdy, and Nevada rarely lights up the scoreboard, so laying the points is risky business and the better bet should be a low-scoring game.

Best Bet: Hawaii-Nevada Under 40.5

Last week: 1-4 against the spread
Season: 35-22-6

For more Week 12 college football best bets and analysis, visit the College Football Week 12 Betting Hub, exclusively on VSiN.

For more picks for this week’s games, visit the VSiN Pro Picks page.

Who does the betting public like in tonight’s games? The VSiN Betting Splits pages show up-to-the-minute betting action from DraftKings and Circa.

Subscribe to VSiN Pro to get Matt Youmans’ picks throughout the season, plus picks from our experts across all major sports.

See what our Opta projections predict for this week’s NFL and NBA action.

Download VSiN’s Betting Guides for an in-depth look at every major sport to help you identify the best value bets.