College Football Week 12 Best Bets, Predictions and Picks from Steve Makinen:
I picked a lot of games last week in college football, 26 in fact, and it didn’t hurt my success rate, as I put together a 15-11 ATS record. It was the biggest board of the season, and if you think about it, it was actually about the same usual percentage of games that I typically take. As it stands, it was my fourth consecutive winning week since I decided to take Week 6 off for my “mental break.” In that four-week span, I’ve gone 50-31 ATS to up my season best bets mark now to 103-88-1 ATS (53.9%), this in spite on particularly bad 5-14 result from Week 6. This week’s slate is just a game smaller and the VSiN College Football Analytics Report is as loaded as it has been all season long, so let’s see what I have come up with for Week 12.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Central Michigan (+1.5) at Buffalo
In most cases, when a team 7-3 overall and 5-1 in conference play is hosting a 5-5 team that is 3-3 in conference, you would figure that you’d see a line of -7 or higher for that home team. Furthermore, that host team has won five straight games and covered six in a row. For Wednesday night, Buffalo is just -1.5 over Central Michigan. So, what’s the deal? Perhaps the oddsmakers consider these teams equal or even CMU having a slight edge, agreeing with my effective play-by-play ratings that show CMU should be favored by 2.8 points.
The Chippewas have also been very good defensively the last couple of weeks, setting up this nice system: Teams that have won back-to-back conference games both SU and ATS while being defensively dominant (<12 PPG allowed in those two games), have been tremendous when playing on the road in the next game, 67-36 ATS (65%) since 2019. Getting back to Buffalo’s current win streak, teams either on four-game ATS winning streaks or four-game ATS losing streaks have been bad bets as small favorites (-4.5 or shorter) in the next contest, going just 95-106 SU and 80-118-3 ATS (40.4%) since 2016.
College Football Best Bet: Let’s ride with Central Michigan as the short dog Wednesday night
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Rice (+3) at Temple
There aren’t many situations in any given college football season when a standalone feature game is as ugly as this one between Rice and Temple. When two struggling teams meet like this, my first thought is to find any reason either team has earned the right to be favored. I don’t see one in this game, and looking at Temple’s home chalk games, the home Owls have lost outright in all of their last three tries this season vs. FBS foes. One of those was last week against UAB, a 36-10 decision, setting up this angle in play for Thursday: Conference home favorites coming off a double-digit conference loss are just 229-316 ATS (42%) since 2016. Rice hasn’t doesn’t have a whole lot to speak of this season, but the road Owls did put up 72 points in their most recent two road contests, and they do have a slight edge on my Effective Play-by-play ratings (should be +1.3). Rice also shows 30% bets but 65% handle at DraftKings on the splits as of Wednesday. Typically, this means sharp money is on that side.
College Football Best Bets: Give me Rice +3 at Temple on Thursday night
Friday, November 20, 2026
Iowa State (+2.5) at UCF
Iowa State was generally picked to be at or near the bottom of the Big 12 standings this season. I’m not sure most people thought a bowl game was in the cards for this first season under new head coach Jimmy Rogers. That said, the Cyclones stand on the doorstep of a bowl bid, needing one more win to wrap that up. They’ll need to get it here or next week versus Kansas State. For this Friday, my Effective Play-by-play lines show a slight edge on the point spread to ISU of 0.9 points. My power ratings show a similar number, a 1.1-point edge. In other words, the strength ratings suggest this game will be very competitive.
A few trend angles tip the scales for me. First, UCF has lost 15 of its last 17 games ATS as a favorite in conference play. The Knights are also in a system showing conference home favorites coming off a double-digit conference loss are just 229-316 ATS (42%) since 2016. They got beat by 13 at home by ASU last week. Finally, Iowa State is well-known as a program that thrives in the underdog role, 21-12 (63.6%) ATS as such since 2021
College Football Best Bet: Let’s go with Iowa State +2.5 at the Bounce House on Friday night
Bowling Green at Toledo (-16.5)
Toledo needs a win to stay in the MAC title-game hunt, and a recent nemesis comes to town. Despite its overall superiority lately, the Rockets have struggled with Bowling Green, going 1-3 SU and 0-4 ATS in the last four tries. Does head coach Eddie George’s 2026 BGSU team have what it takes to keep Toledo from its conference title goals? At 3-7, you wouldn’t think so, especially with Toledo in revenge mode and coming off a shutout win last week. Look at the revenge angle in play: College football teams seeking revenge and having at least four more wins on the season than their opponent have been very successful, going 117-24 SU and 88-48-5 ATS (64.7%) since 2016.
My metrics also support a comfortable Toledo win: power ratings show this line should be -17.3, and the Effective Play-by-play line shows the Rockets at -26.7. The betting public seems to be getting sucked toward BGSU as well, with over 72% of the handle there, yet the line is moving toward Toledo. The stakes, the team strength, and the revenge motivation all favor the Rockets.
College Football Best Bet: I’ll back Toledo -15.5 at home over Bowling Green
Oregon at Michigan State (Total 44.5)
Oregon seems to be finding a groove finally behind QB Dylan Raiola, putting up 106 points in the last three games against solid defenses in Northwestern, Ohio State, and Michigan. That is like putting up about 50 PPG on average in those contests, since those teams effectively allow just 10 PPG between the three. That trend would put the Ducks on pace for about 40 points here, and the total for Friday night in East Lansing is just 44.5. It would seem that the betting public is catching on to this, as over 80% of the bets for this game as of Wednesday night are on the Over. That shouldn’t be a problem, as since the start of the 2022 season, on games with totals of 46.5 or lower, 72%+ supermajority number of bets bettors bucking the low total and siding with the Over have gone 232-218. With Oregon shown as a 16.5-point road favorite here, there is also a nice total system in place: Big 10 home underdogs of >= 11.5 points in Weeks 11 or later in the season have gone Over the total at a 25-9 (73.5%) rate in conference play since 2017. The Spartans have also averaged 25 PPG at home this season and will need to score to be competitive here.
College Football Best Bet: I’ll go Over 44.5 on the Oregon-Michigan State total
New Mexico at Wyoming (+7.5/37.5)
Strange to see a battle for a conference title showing a 7.5-point road favorite, but it’s merely a sign of the variance in respect that New Mexico and Wyoming have had this season. The Lobos were expected to be in this position, although they effectively lost their shot at a CFP berth with the setback versus UNLV last week. Road favorites coming off a close loss of 10 points or fewer are just 84-116-1 ATS (42%) since 2022. Also, teams that lose in a college football game as favorites of 19.5 points or more have gone just 45-73 SU and 44-70-4 ATS (38.6%) in the follow-up contest since 2012.
Wyoming started slow but has come on like gangbusters after everyone forgot about them. My effective play-by-play line shows the Cowboys should only be a +4.5-point dog here and they are 18-5 ATS (78.3%) in their last 23 games as a home conference underdog. This game also shows two great total systems to consider: 1) Teams coming off of four straight SU wins and are now playing as a large underdog (+7 or more) to a conference opponent with a better scoring defense on the year have meant heavy Unders – 44-22 (66.7%) since 2016. 2) Home underdogs coming off of four straight SU wins have trended Under the total at a 54-35-2 (60.7%) rate since 2016. I believe this game will be a slugfest that either team can win.
College Football Best Bet: Give me Wyoming +7.5 and/or Under 37.5 vs. New Mexico for Friday
Look for my picks for Saturday’s games later this evening.
For more Week 12 college football best bets, visit the Week 12 College Football Betting Hub, exclusively on VSiN.com.
For more pro picks for tonight’s games, visit the VSiN Pro Picks page.
Who does the betting public like in tonight’s games? The VSiN Betting Splits pages show up-to-the-minute betting action from DraftKings and Circa.
Subscribe to VSiN Pro to get Steve Makinen’s data-driven best bets throughout the season, plus picks from our experts across all major sports.
See what our Opta projections predict for this week’s NFL and NBA action.
Download VSiN’s Betting Guides for an in-depth look at every major sport to help you identify the best value bets.





