Daily Racing Form expert handicapper and analyst Marcus Hersh handicaps the Saturday, April 11 racing card at Keeneland, including his projected 1-2-3 finishers. His best bet of the day comes from Race 3.
Also, view FREE DRF Past Performances for today’s Race of the Day.
BEST BET: Eye Dee Kay (3rd race)
Third Race
1. Eye Dee Kay
2. Fountain Run
3. Hope Joe’s Right
EYE DEE KAY got eligible for this $12.5K starter when he aired for a $10K tag in December at FG. Claimed, ran back twice for $30K, gave the capable Glen Airie a tussle in his last start, from which he was claimed again. In other words, a very strong class fit. Yet to try 1 1/8 miles, but I think he’ll handle that. Lone workout video during time he’s been freshened and pointed to this is the 3/31 drill at CD – didn’t just get the bullet (short work tab that day, to be sure) but looked very good doing it. I like FOUNTAIN RUN to come out atop a pace battle with Money Run but eventually lose the war to EDK. Draw a line through the last-out OP slop flop and find a competitive horse. HOPE JOE’S RIGHT out of lower-level conditioned claimers and into a solid starter race, but he’s not exposed on dirt and has the right style to bubble up for a share if a speed duel percolates.
Here are Marcus’ thoughts on the other ten races on Saturday’s Keeneland card.
First Race
1. Nuts and Bolts
2. Buckeye Bombshell
3. Speed Skater
Trainer K McPeek with maiden claimers at the Keeneland spring meet is a thing. 2023-25 Aprils the barn is 11-5-0-2 in such races. Don’t want to make too much of it, because there always can be reasons we don’t know, but Brian Hernandez is 100% the top stable rider; he rode neither NUTS AND BOLTS nor BUCKEYE BOMBSHELL in their last start, and winds up on stretchout sprinter Nuts and Bolts. Less flashy trainer stats with the sprint-route maiden-claiming move, but not like it’s never happened. While bred like a sprinter miler, the siblings all have been sprinters, yet this horse has a stride that suggests a route is in play. Galloped out decently in second start after turning in the fastest final furlong. Buckeye Bombshell’s last four starts came on turf, but his lone dirt route, last summer in a CNL MSW, was fast enough to win this. Almost always losing ground from stretch call to wire – not a great habit. SPEED SKATER goes for trainer B Cox, 3-13 wins over the last five years with Keeneland spring maiden-claimers. Somewhat better second out with blinkers on, though that could just have been second start improvement and a class drop, too. Hard to see him sustaining a long run on dirt if he’s not able to get into the race quicker.
Second Race
1. Standard Deduction
2. Beale Street Boy
3. Gentleman Jim
STANDARD DEDUCTION doing what a young horse, even a modest maiden-claimer, is supposed to do – get better with racing! Flow of his last out somewhat in his favor. Easy winner got first run and was dropping from maiden $30K down to $15K. On pedigree and style, the extra furlong here should help. And for a horse at this level, he appeared to work really well over a sealed KEE surface on April 2, going very easily around the turn before quickening sharply when asked in the stretch. BEALE STREET BOY looked much better in a pair of February works at KEE than he ran in March at CNL. Blinkers were on one race last year, go back on now. They’re looking for answers – class drop part of the equation. Nothing especially noteworthy in sample of B Colebrook-trained MSW to MCL droppers at Keeneland. GENTLEMAN JIM no Lasix and MSW foes in his lone dirt start, which wasn’t bad.
Fourth Race
1. Shewontbudge
2. Pinto
3. Rockin Robin
SHEWONTBUDGE looks best on paper and the Payson workout video is—whoosh. From this point of view, very strong drills. Not going to go on at length about her because she’s clearly competitive on paper and will be a short price. PINTO, after starting a serious work pattern on 11/26, missed more than a month of working (1/10 – 2/15) at FG and did take three weeks to work back after shipping north to CD. Only breeze video is from last fall – looked far from fully fit but potentially talented. Would have to be to take down the favorite. ROCKIN ROBIN just keeps running generally the same “not quite good enough for MSW” race. She’s done that running long, but also in a KEE sprint last fall.
Fifth Race
1. Tilson
2. Minotaur
3. Comprehensive
The only two workout videos for first-time starter TILSON came on dirt, and this is a turf horse. Even those drills offered encouraging signs! Already gelded, which can be a good thing with a young horse who’s proving unruly for whatever reason, and is the first foal from the multiple Grade 1-winning middle-distance grass horse Cambier Parc. Trainer Walden with first-time starters that went off at 10-1 or lower in turf-route MSWs 9-2-2-2. MINOTAUR had very compromising trouble in both his starts. Finished fastest and galloped out in front in debut, and in the second start got buzzed late by an outside flowing cavalry. With a clean run, he just might prove good enough. Unlucky or unwilling? That’s the question to be asked at a short price of COMPREHENSIVE, the likely favorite after three straight near misses in races similar to this one.
Sixth Race
1. Conquest Warrior
2. Authentic Strike
3. Curlin’s Malibu
CONQUEST WARRIOR moved somewhat early into a very strong pace in a 2/19 FG race at this class level. That marked his first start in the better part of two years – had every right to get a little tired. Race won by his stablemate, Corporate Power, who also had been off forever and, like CW, was making first start for Asmussen barn. All Corporate Power did in his next start was nearly win the G2 New Orleans Classic. This one, it appears they’ve been sitting on, awaiting KEE. Would be nice if he could get a little more early position. AUTHENTIC STRIKE also tired late in his last start, and also was returning from a long break, some 16 months. And, like Conquest Warrior, he bid somewhat early into a hot pace, came up a little short, and has been aimed – seemingly — at this very spot. Blowout MSW score in lone KEE race. Not totally, entirely sold he stays 9f. CURLIN’S MALIBU raced for a $32K tag in August and subsequently got into a couple $8K starters, so the $80K claim price in his first start since 12/29 seems like a strong positive indicator, especially coupled with the work pattern.
Seventh Race
1. Noble Confessor
2. Arkhipov
3. Rocky Joy
Imagine they stretched NOBLE CONFESSOR out to longer distances last year because he lacks a real turn of foot and does better going a steady pace. Still think he can win at this shorter trip – in great part because he landed in a field lacking a lot of proven quality. Clearly got too much of a taxing tempo 2/28, making first start in nearly three months. Figures to run at a target this time and can nab that overdue second career win – perhaps at a fair price owing to the presence of ARKHIPOV. While he won by a wide margin last out at Tampa, to me the visual fell short of the high-speed figure. It was a soft group of maidens, as well, and I’d guess he’s significantly overbet on this class hike. ROCKY JOY is better on turf than Tapeta, where he made his most recent start, and has run well on KEE grass both spring and fall. He also has eight runner-up finishes and one win.
Eighth Race
1. Al Ghadeer
2. Right Timing
3. Epic Proud Mary
AL GHADEER’s debut and lone start came in an 11-horse field of at least decent quality last fall at CD. She didn’t have a terrible trip, but neither was it a good one – in traffic around turn and had to wait. Finished with plenty of interest and hit the wire well enough. First work after November race came 1/26 at KEE, and she has drilled fairly steadily since – surely this long has been the target. Two recent work videos, and the 3/21 breeze in particular encouraged. Not sure just how much there is in this race. RIGHT TIMING beaten as odds-on fave in TAM debut but had nine lengths on the third horse and ran just fine in defeat. Horse that beat her came back and finished a close second in a two-turn TAM N1X allowance. One work video post-race, 3/21, outside Point of Reference, who one week later scored a second-start AQU MSW win, 72 Beyer. RT worked fine – seemed like they wanted more out of her mate. Would guess she does not lead this time. The one horse for which I could find no work video is the first-timer that looked most interesting on paper, EPIC PROUD MARY. Flying blind.
Ninth Race
1. Lush Lips
2. Destino d’Oro
3. Segesta
As good as LUSH LIPS already has gotten, she can still get better. Absolutely versatile running style can come in handy in a race lacking real pace. She used to lead but has become an even better horse employing a stalk-and-pounce style, and I don’t think she’s ever finished with as much zip as she showed making her 4yo bow in the Honey Fox at short-stretch Gulfstream. Subsequent work video – thumbs up. DESTINO D’ORO is way, way better than the horse Lush Lips mushed in the QE II last fall. Handy, athletic, a very nice burst, and she won last time despite coming from a very difficult position after getting steadied and shuffled back early on the far turn. SEGESTA ended her 4yo campaign like she’s set for a career year at age 5. No workout video for her, but surely the barn has her all set for a representative showing in her ’26 debut. Just missed in the G1 First Lady last fall at KEE, but that was a below-par renewal. I can’t see her being as high as 7-2 – surely she’s meaningfully shorter than Destino d’Oro, who’s listed at 4-1.
Tenth Race
1. The Hell We Did
2. Confessional
3. Decisive Win
Obviously, THE HELL WE DID was beating no graded-stakes horses in a Sunland Park first-level allowance. I loved the way he looked in the race. Showed at least a little flash as a 2yo, but looked like a different horse coming back from a winter break. The dam is just an ace broodmare – all her horses can go at least a mile, Saudi Cup winner Senor Buscador the best of them. Would guess this horse gets bet lower than the listed odds, but still likely a decent number. CONFESSIONAL was a very grindy third in the VA Derby, though he did stay on decently in the very late going. Can probably do somewhat better than that – but how much? Already had three races this year. Like him better than the other gray B Cox-trained starter, Ezum. They worked together and I preferred Confessional. DECISIVE WIN ran into a good winner in a pace-and-fade debut – not a bad effort. They have high hopes, shipping from CA to KY for a graded route race off a debut sprint defeat. The April 3 drill looks good on paper – and just as good on video.
Eleventh Race
1. West End Kid 2. Heeere’s Johnny 3. Royal Guard
Granted, I am what some actual trainers like to call a “Twitter trainer,” but in my humble opinion, WEST END KID looks like a prime candidate for the blinkers-on move here. He didn’t get away very well and was well back coming off the club turn – to the extent that the jockey flicked a rein at his mount, trying to move forward into a better position. Not only did he get no response, the horse appeared to come off the bridle and suck even further out of contention into the far turn. This would all be “whatever” but for the fact that after getting checked between horses straightening for home, WEK proceeded to finish fastest and win the gallop-out. Work pattern says he’s been aimed at KEE ever since, and with luck, he could take down deserving favorite HEEERE’S JOHNNY. You know who quietly ran pretty well in the BC Juvenile Turf? Heeere’s Johnny, is who. Broke inward and slowly and rider had little choice but to sit at the back of the pack. He tried to follow a three-wide mover partway down the backstretch and into the far turn, but that horse didn’t really take him where he needed to go, and rather than pitch out into the middle of the course on the bend, the jockey just had to wait until the homestretch to make a run. HJ made a good one! Plenty of work for ’26 bow. Just has a knack for not winning, is the thing. ROYAL GUARD’s lone turf race came in a SAR MSW route of modest quality, but he was four wide without cover on both turns and still finished pretty well. There’s one work video for first-timer COORDINATOR, and it suggested he can run, but he’s drawn very wide, and the ace trainer, FWIW, has nearly no history running first-timers in turf routes at the KEE meet – just two such starters the last five years, neither making much impact.
Daily Racing Form is the most trusted source for horse racing news and information. Get an edge when you play the races with DRF.com.
For complete Derby Watch Top 20 rankings, visit DRF.com – Derby Watch analyzes top Kentucky Derby contenders each week. For odds, past performances and expert picks, visit DRF.com
Put yourself in position to win big this year with DRF’s Kentucky Derby Package. Top data and trusted picks all in one place.
Get more Daily Racing Form horse racing picks on a daily basis on our VSiN Horse Racing page.
