NFL Survivor

What a week it is for Survivor players. We have five double-digit favorites on the board and others that are a touchdown or higher. It is such a chalky week in the NFL that the possibilities are seemingly endless.

Of course, that is, if you haven’t already used those teams or have to hold them back for the upcoming holiday weeks. Next week is the Thanksgiving “week” and that means two picks will be required in Circa Survivor for those who are playing in that contest or a similar one with those rules. Some of the big favorites this week are either in play next week or for the Christmas holiday, which means that you’ll have to choose wisely and carefully.

As always, I’m trying to keep the information as relevant as possible and I’m not doubling up any teams that I suggest, even though I’ve picked a trio of outright losers so far. It doesn’t do me, you, or anybody else any good if I tell you to take the 49ers every week or something like that. It especially doesn’t do much good this week because they are not one of the best options on the board.

Alright, you have the tools. You have some options. Now it’s time to look at this week’s possibilities.

Once again, we’ll be using the Survivor tools from PoolGenius to plot out a course for the season and evaluate the pool picks each week.

Week 11 NFL Survivor Teams to Consider

Texans (-12.5) over Colts

Thursday Night Football was pretty popular two weeks ago when the Jaguars played the severely-shorthanded Ravens. It was a lot less popular last week with the Commanders and Giants. But, this week, we have a massive favorite on Amazon Prime.

As difficult as it is for me to wrap my head around a 3-6 team inching close to being a two-touchdown favorite, that is the reality of the situation for these two teams. The Texans should not be 3-6 with the way that C.J. Stroud is playing, but they are. The Colts have earned their 3-7 record and had an accompanying fire sale to boot.

What is also wild about this huge line is that the Colts beat the Texans earlier this season in what was probably Stroud’s worst game of the season, as he was just 16-of-27 for 167 yards. Neither team generated explosive plays in that game, as the Colts averaged 4.2 yards per play and the Texans just 4.4. I guess we’re all assuming that the Texans will right the ship here?

As things stand, per our Circa Survivor dashboard, 37.7% of the field, or 214 entries, still have the Texans available. However, they are a Christmas team on the road at Philadelphia. Per PoolGenius, the Texans are the likeliest Christmas week winner at 67%. Our numbers have them at 73.6%, even on the road. The Bills are the next highest at 61.2% for the holiday in Week 16.

Fortunately, those who still have the Texans can probably hold off on them with so many other options, but we’ll see what the usage rate is. PoolGenius has the Texans third this week at 85% and our dashboard has them at 84.7% to win. Personally, I used the Texans for this article when they lost to the Giants. Shame on me.

Chiefs (-16) over Cardinals

Only 3.9% of the Circa Survivor field has the Chiefs left, so I’m not going to spend much time on them. I will say that our model has their win probability at 89.9%, mere hundredths of a percent behind the Bills. KC is a Thanksgiving-only team, but that opponent is Buffalo on the road and so a lot of entrants were content with using the earlier in the competition. Personally, for this article, I used them in Week 3.

Cowboys (-8) over Titans

I’m not going to spend much time on this because the Cowboys are pretty clearly the optimal Thanksgiving pick against the Eagles. Our projections say 54.8%, but PoolGenius numbers say 79%. With 88.2% of the field still holding Dallas, expect them to be easily the most popular Thanksgiving selection.

Bears (-11) over Saints

The Bears look like a pretty easy pick to make for those in a traditional contest that doesn’t have the holiday “weeks”. Unfortunately, in Circa Survivor, the Bears play on both holidays. They are at Detroit for Thanksgiving and host Green Bay for Christmas. It certainly isn’t an easy choice to make to take them this week with that knowledge. Even though we are down to a very small percentage of the field, we’re still likely to go the distance with this contest based on the number of entries and available teams.

There is a reason why 88.2% of the Circa Survivor field still has the Bears per our dashboard. It’s because of that holiday two-step. The only teams with more availability are the Chargers, Bucs, Titans, Cardinals, Dolphins, Jets, Giants, Saints, and Raiders. It would have been pretty hard to find spots to take them. But, the Bears are a very good team that everybody is keeping in the chamber until firing a holiday bullet.

That’s the case again this week if you’re in a Circa-style Survivor. You cannot afford to take them here and be left short an option for either holiday. Fortunately, there are big favorites left. PoolGenius has the Bears at 83% to win this week, while our dashboard shows 83.2%.

Bills (-16.5) over Dolphins

This is the most agonizing team of the week because this looks like an easy one. This looks like an uncontested, Dominique Wilkins down-the-lane slam dunk. Sadly, the Bills, like the Bears, are a double holiday team. It’s borderline cruel.

Buffalo hosts Kansas City for the Thanksgiving “week” and visits Denver for the Christmas “week”. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that either one of those spots and those matchups would be classified as “awesome”, but I’m going to tell you the same thing I told you with the Bears. You cannot burn them here. I mean, you can. You can do whatever you want to do. It’s your money and your equity. But, it is a hard choice to make given that Buffalo is projected to be a favorite in both of those games.

Passing on a 92% win probability per PoolGenius and an 89.9% probability per our dashboard is just brutal. But, that’s the game. For what it’s worth, 78.2% of the Circa Survivor field has the Bills left. I’m curious to see how they play it.

Chargers (-3) over Jets

Can I interest you in a 1-9 football team with your $1,000 Survivor entry that is now worth over $44,000 in equity? Look, I don’t like this idea either, but I would be shocked if nobody took the Chargers. The entirety of the field, all 568 remaining entries, have the Chargers available. Our projections give them a 62.3% win probability and PoolGenius says 59%.

It seems extremely counterintuitive, if not downright stupid, to take the Chargers with five very large favorites and a couple of medium-sized favorites on the board. However, if you want to keep all of the holiday teams in play, this is one way to do so.

By the way, the Chargers host the Patriots in Week 12 and are 66% to win per PoolGenius and 70.2% by our numbers. You’re going to see them in this article again.

Panthers (-2.5) over Ravens

This is another spot like the Chargers, though I’d say decidedly more dangerous, even though the line isn’t all that different. Per our dashboard, 85.9% of the remaining entries have Carolina available. Can you trust them to beat a Ravens team that is starting Jacoby Brissett at QB and has lost five games in a row?

Baltimore has two recent three-point losses. Their other losses are by 22, 26, and 23. The season is slipping away. Meanwhile, Carolina is in the thick of the NFC South race because nobody in that division is any good. Baltimore has been outscored 32-13 over the last four games. They haven’t had a lead in any of their last three games.

The Panthers, like the Chargers, are not a holiday team. They are 54% to win this week per PoolGenius and 56.4% per our projections.

NFL Week 11 Survivor Pick

Broncos (-10) over Raiders

Fernando Mendoza showed flashes in his first game with the Raiders, but not enough to beat the Seahawks. Now he’s on the road to take on the Broncos and we’ve seen Denver money push this out to 10, with some books threatening to maybe go back to 9.5. This will shock you, but guess what? Denver is a double holiday team, too!

There is a conundrum here, though. So, Denver plays at Pittsburgh for the Thanksgiving “week” and hosts Buffalo for the Christmas “week.” Therefore, you could conceivably make a really strong case to go ahead and use them this week. Now, the downside risk is that Josh Allen gets hurt and maybe Denver is the best, or at least a much better, Christmas option. There’s also the chance that Aaron Rodgers gets hurt this week and Denver becomes more palatable for Thanksgiving.

Per PoolGenius, Denver’s 42% win probability against Buffalo is the third-lowest of the Christmas week, ahead of only the Packers at the Bears and the Eagles at home against the Texans. Our projection is even less optimistic at 38.8%, better than only the Eagles at 26.4%. 

Given that 78.5% of the field has Denver, I’m very interested in this pick. I think the Raiders are also dangerous enough and talented enough to possibly pull the upset, as they can play a higher-variance style of game than the other big underdogs.

But, that’s the risk I’m going to take here. With Dallas at my disposal for Thanksgiving and a better option than fading the Bills on Christmas, it’ll be Denver for me, as they come off of the bye to face a rookie QB in his second start.

Pick: Broncos

Teams Used: Jaguars, Buccaneers, Chiefs, Vikings, Bengals, 49ers, Texans, Bengals, Seahawks, Ravens

Follow the link for the rest of our NFL Week 10 content.